4 Comments
User's avatar
Josh Datko's avatar

Catching up on your other recommendations. The "hate substack" piece is interesting. I've done published and magazine stuff before but mostly technical non-fiction. I've had editors work with me but I don't know, it was a utopia.

Then there's the feedback. Someone would have to write a letter to the editor or such, than that will have to filter back to the author.

I feel like substack is more like a newspaper. Well it even started as a platform for newsletters! Tomorrow, there will be another post. Ooops there is a mistake, we can just edit the post after the fact.

It's very ephemeral. So I'd argue that the mediums that are more permanent (books, vinyl records) probably deserve a higher degree of editorial review.

Graeme McAllister's avatar

That's a good point... I think that creative writing is in a similar place to the music industry. The more transient, disposable forms of physical media are being replaced by digital formats - the CD with streaming, the magazine with online articles.

However the luxury physical formats are enjoining a surge. The special edition vinyl, the illuminated hardback manuscrip ...

Josh Datko's avatar

Very kind, thank you. Thanks for listening too -- I realize substack is visual heavy so I appreciate it when readers also engage with the audio.

Also, this is a very nice thing you are doing here. I looking forward to reading the other work here but thank you for helping to elevate this community.

Graeme McAllister's avatar

Thank you for your excellent work